Skip to main content

Food Trends: diet sodas not so much of a diet

I am so torn about diet sodas.  On the one hand I love that they are calorie free, on the other hand even though aspartame, splenda, and saccharin have been deemed generally recommended as safe, I still recommend keeping consumption down.  What do I mean when I say “keep consumption down?”  That is a good question. I probably only consume products that have all or any of the above a couple of times a week and do the same with my children.  I have no rhyme or reason for this, except that I prefer whole, natural foods. I do dislike the calories in any drink other than milk and will opt for a lower calorie option when available. 

I’m always on the lookout for research and when one of my peers posted results from the studies below I thought it would be great to share.  Recently, scientific presentations at the American Diabetic Association showed that aspartame and diet sodas may attribute to pre Diabetes or Diabetes and weight gain. 

The first study completed at the University of Texas San Antonio monitored 474 people 65-74 years of age for ten years.  After assessing and following patients for about 9.5 years researchers found that those who drank two or more diet sodas a day increased their waist circumference by seventy percent.

In another study, mice were fed two diets. One diet contained chow which included corn oil to promote high fat and the other diet contained chow which included corn oil and aspartame.  After three months, the mice were assessed and the mice who consumed the corn oil and aspartame chow had high blood sugars.  These results suggest that aspartame could possibly contribute to high blood sugars, although results from mice cannot be directly correlated with humans.

The hypothesis from the first study is that the sweetness from diet sodas may trigger appetite but not quench hunger secondary to inappropriate metabolic responses. The thought is that this in turn inhibits brain cells from feeling full and can possibly contribute to overeating until your body tells you it is finally full.  The study mentions that they evaluated physical exercise and chronic co morbitities, but it does not provide information on monitoring of calories or food intake.

As for the second study, I am at a loss of words.  Aspartame is broken down into amino acids which normally do not cause any reaction in terms of blood sugars.  I am looking very forward to more information on this.

In any case, perhaps these studies will make you think twice about consuming more than two diet sodas a day.  It’s always important to take a look at your total calorie consumption in a day to assess true nutritional status.  If you need help, contact a dietitian.  Until next time, be well.
To drink or not to drink diet sodas... that is the question


Spencer Kline said…
I find all this very interesting and have tried to quite drinking diet soda since reading this research. Could aspartame raise blood sugar levels changing our sensation relating to what is sweet and cause our brain in many ways to lose it bearings?
Steffi said…
Hey, nice site you have here! Keep up the excellent work!

Pre Diabetes Diet

Popular posts from this blog

Insightful Intern - Eating to Lose Weight

In order to lose weight, we often are told that energy out must be greater than energy in.   In other words, calories taken in must be less than the calories we use in all of our daily activities.  So, to lose weight we cut calories and try to increase activity.  (Granted, there is more to weight loss/maintenance than just an exchange in energy.  What if we cut too many calories or don’t eat enough?
Since I started at Kindred Nutrition, I’ve heard many of Amy’s or Dawn’s clients talk about how they’ve cut back on calories to lose weight but have hit a weight-loss plateau.  Many a time when a client discusses this occurrence, we eventually come to the conclusion that the client is not eating enough.  This probably sounds foreign but you do need to eat in order to lose weight!  If you’re not eating enough your body goes into “starvation mode.”   Then whenever you do eat your body automatically stores those calories as fat because it is worried that it is not going to get enough calorie…

Food Trends: Macros Misconstrued

Oh Macros, how I love thee. You are the foundation of my nutrition recommendations. You should be individualized and different for everyone although you are "prescribed" routinely the same person to person. You are scientific, there is not a one size fits all, and frankly you are misunderstood.

A couple of years ago Macros started to become more popular in the www world when a brilliant someone decided to market magical macro percentages to induce weight loss, body massing, and everything else under the sun. The thought process is to start with grams of protein needs dependent on body weight, to then look at range of fats between 25-35% dependent on goals and body type, and to provide the remaining of your macro goals from carbohydrates.  How easy, especially since everyone has the same protein needs, insert sarcasm here.

Right away many bought into this bullet proof hope and we now have too many folks determining and "prescribing" ratios for people who aren't …

Insightful Intern: Meet Maryellen

We've been so lucky at Kindred Nutrition this year to have two great interns. Read below to see how a student athlete views her experience so far at Kindred Nutrition. We can't wait to follow her season this year!
I’m Maryellen Hauver and I am one of the interns spending time at Kindred Nutrition this summer. I just completed my sophomore year at Bridgewater College, studying Nutritional Science. As I got into my major at school, I began to consider what job I would like to use my degree for after school. In my classes I mostly heard about working as a Registered Dietitian. Before choosing this as my career of pursuit, I wanted to get some experience that would help me understand exactly what the job entails. Knowing that I would be home for the summer, I did some research about dietitians in the Frederick area. Through the magic of Google, I found Amy! I also discovered this blog and saw that she had taken college student interns in the past. It appeared to be the perfect op…